The team investigates the 1964 murder of Miriam Forrester, a Tupperware saleswoman when her sister appears with a threatening letter sent to Miriam from Missisippi.
- Kathryn Morris as Lilly Rush
- Danny Pino as Scotty Valens
- John Finn as John Stillman
- Jeremy Ratchford as Nick Vera
- Thom Barry as Will Jeffries
- Tracie Thoms as Kat Miller
- Alexandra Lydon as Miriam Forrester
- Chris Ellis as Jim Horn (2008)
- Jenna Leigh Green as Violet Golding (1964)
- Jennifer Hetrick as Lana Wilkes (2008)
- Rob Mayes as Jim Horn (1964)
- Kathleen Nolan as Kitty Doyle (2008)
- Demond Robertson as Cordell Baker (1964)
- Concetta Tomei as Violet Golding (2008)
- Vernee Watson as Belinda Hutchins (2008)
- Tinashe Kajese as Belinda Hutchins (1964)
- Toi Perkins as Debra Nelson (1964)
- Angela Sargeant as Debra Nelson (2008)
- Eric Mark Fischer as Friend #1 (1964)
- Trisha LaFache as Kitty Doyle (1964)
- Maddy Kennedy as Lana Wilkes (1964)
- Julia Pace Mitchell as Ella Turner (1964)
- Travis Willingham as Uniform Cop (1964)
- John Finn directed this episode, the first to be directed by a member of the cast.
- The closing song is performed by cast member Tracie Thoms.
- This episode was apparently based on the real-life 1965 murder of Viola Liuzzo.
- The Kinks "You Really Got Me"
- Bobby Vinton "Blue Velvet"
- Dionne Warwick "Walk On By"
- The Supremes "Come See About Me"
- "Nearer My God to Thee"
- Jimmy Collier and the Movement Singers "Will The Circle Be Unbroken"
- Closing Song: "This Little Light of Mine" performed by Tracie Thoms