Blood from a man arrested in West Virginia matches blood found at the scene after a Philadephia woman was abducted from her engagement party in 2007. As Lilly and Scotty drive the man, known only as "John Smith" back to Philly, they soon learn he had abducted other women before, imprisoning them until they give up hope, and then finally letting them die. When they realize his latest victim may still be alive, the ride back becomes a battle of wills as Lilly and Scotty try to force John Smith to give up her location before her time runs out.
- Kathryn Morris as Lilly Rush
- Danny Pino as Scotty Valens
- John Finn as John Stillman
- Jeremy Ratchford as Nick Vera
- Thom Barry as Will Jeffries
- Tracie Thoms as Kat Miller
- Damon Herriman as John Smith (2008)
- Kevin Cooney as Deputy Sheriff Ted Huffard
- Jeff Hephner as David Nelson
- Kathleen Munroe as Brenda MacDowell
- Jayne Taini as Dotty Phillips
- Annie Abrams as Monica Capcot
- Field Cate as John Smith (1983)
- Stevie Johnson as Newark Resident
- Eileen Grubba as Colleen Legarth
- Kristen Faye Hunter as Young Woman (1983)
- Sunil Malhotra as Cocky Dude (2007)
- Michael Proctor as Male Party Guest
- Jonathan Strait as Colleen's Husband
- Kincaid Walker as Hot Woman (2007)
- "Somewhere Over The Rainbow" by Israel Kamakawiwo'ole was also used in the Season 2 episode "Wishing"
- Rihanna "Umbrella"
- Gnarls Barkley "Crazy"
- Israel Kamakawiwo'ole "Somewhere Over The Rainbow"
- Absinthe Blind "Bands 2"
- Liza Germano "Red Thread"
- Closing Song: OneRepublic "Come Home"