After disovering she was adopted as a baby, a woman asks Lilly to investigate the murder of her birth mother in 1964. Her mother was a teenager sent to a church-run home for unwed mothers before her murder. As Lilly and the detectives investigate, the now-defunct home's dark secrets begin to come out.
- Kathryn Morris as Lilly Rush
- Danny Pino as Scotty Valens
- John Finn as John Stillman
- Jeremy Ratchford as Nick Vera
- Thom Barry as Will Jeffries
- Bruce Boxleitner as Huck Oberland (2007)
- Johanna Braddy as Hilary West
- Elizabeth Connors as Patricia West (1964)
- Georgann Johnson as Sister Margaret (2007)
- Sandy Martin as Karen Watson (2007)
- Michelle Page as Karen Watson (1964)
- Bree Pavey as Sister Margaret (1964)
- Patricia Place as Patricia West (2007)
- Andy Fischer-Price as Huck Oberland (1964)
- Sterling Beaumon as Brat #1
- Jillian Boyd as Barbara Lakey (2007)
- Jordan Green as Brat #2
- Butch Hammett as Bill West (1964)
- Leslie Murphy as Singing Pregnant Girl #2
- Joss Saltzman as Huck's Grandson ("Boy")
- Delia Sweeney as Singing Pregnant Girl #1
- Unknown actor as Dr. Finnegan
- Unknown actress as Mary-Lou McLaren
- Unknown actress as Sister Abigail
- At the end of the episode, Hillary's case box is put away next to Simone Marks' case box. Rather ironic, given the theme of this episode.
- Stillman and Jeffries both reference Stillman's older brother brother, Father Andrew Stillman.
- The Supremes "Baby Love"
- Ben E. King "Stand By Me"
- Michael A. Levine "The Park"
- The Four Tops "Baby I Need Your Lovin'"
- The Supremes "Were Did Our Love Go"
- Brenda Lee "Losing You"
- Closing Song: Carly Simon "You Are My Sunshine"