The team reinvestigates the 1978 murder of Missy Gallavan, a 15 year old roller skater who was found in a ravine when a convicted thief reveals some information regarding her death in order to get a lighter sentence.
- Kathryn Morris as Lilly Rush
- Danny Pino as Scotty Valens
- John Finn as John Stillman
- Jeremy Ratchford as Nick Vera
- Thom Barry as Will Jeffries
- Tracie Thoms as Kat Miller
- Holland Roden as Missy Gallavan
- Bonnie Burroughs as Julie Reed (2008)
- Peter Giles as Joe Bosquay (1978)
- Lindsey Haun as Julie Reed (1978)
- Jesse Jensen as Rick Rendell (1978)
- Deborah May as Simone Gallavan (2008)
- John Posey as Rick Rendell (2008)
- Anthony Tyler Quinn as Hugh Mastersen (2008)
- Allison Smith as Simone Gallavan (1978)
- Jake Thomas as Hugh Mastersen (1978)
- Earth, Wind & Fire "September"
- Nick Gilder "Hot Child In The City"
- Chic "Good Times"
- Grand Funk Railroad "The Loco-Motion"
- Yvonne Elliman "If I Can't Have You"
- Eddie Money "Two Tickets to Paradise"
- Closing Song: Bob Welch "Sentimental Lady"