The team reopens the case of a dock worker who was moonlighting as an indy-circuit wrestler until he was shot dead in 1986. Meanwhile, Valens secretly looks into a lead on the man who mugged and raped his mother.
- Kathryn Morris as Lilly Rush
- Danny Pino as Scotty Valens
- John Finn as John Stillman
- Jeremy Ratchford as Nick Vera
- Thom Barry as Will Jeffries
- Tracie Thoms as Kat Miller
- J.R. Cacia as Lance Katrola (1986)
- Lauren Cohan as Rachel Malone (1986)
- James Hanlon as Detective Pierson
- Stacey Hinnen as "Sweet" Sil Tavern (1986)
- Scott Anthony Leet as Tim Malone (2010)
- Kevin McNamara as Mick "The Machine" Malone
- Karmin Murcelo as Belen Hernandez
- Roddy Piper as "Sweet" Sil Tavern (2010)
- Theresa Russell as Rachel Malone (2010)
- Bobby Ray Shafer as Nate "Red Scare" Beecher (2010)
- Jay Thomas as Lance Katrola (2010)
- Joni Bovill as Woman (2010)
- Justin McCully as Rob "Bear" Jacobs (1986)
- Michael Scovotti as Nate "Red Scare" Beecher (1986)
- Panuvat Anthony Nanakornpanom as Jimmy Mota (uncredited)
- Jeremy Ratchford does not appear in this episode.
- The real life wrestling league competing with the WIC is mentioned as the WWF, its name at the time, before a lawsuit with the similarly-initialled World Wildlife Fund forced a name change to its present initials of the WWE.
- Bon Jovi "Livin' On a Prayer"
- Ratt "Round and Round"
- Poison "Play Dirty"
- Scorpions "Rock You Like a Hurricane"
- Bon Jovi "Wanted Dead or Alive"