When DNA evidence reveals that a wrong man was convicted for killing 15-year-old Eve Kendall back in 1986, the team re-opens her case in an attempt to find the real killer.
- Kathryn Morris as Lilly Rush
- Danny Pino as Scotty Valens
- John Finn as John Stillman
- Jeremy Ratchford as Nick Vera
- Thom Barry as Will Jeffries
- Josh Hopkins as ADA Jason Kite
- Marisol Nichols as Elisa
- Robin Weigert as Anna Mayes
- Luke Eberl as Wayne Larkin (1986)
- Ronald Hunter as Jim Larkin
- Larry Joshua as Wayne Larkin (2004)
- Rob Moran as Max Tanner (2004)
- Benjamin Parrillo as Mark Adams (2004)
- Anson Scoville as Max Tanner (1986)
- Carrie Armstrong as Carrie Plummer (2004)
- Michael Bierman as Mark Adams (1986)
- Gavin Black as Shopper (1986)
- Blue Deckert as Sam Tarrance (2004)
- Amy Halloran as Carrie Plummer (1986)
- Patricia Sill as Wendy
- Timothy Slaske as Sam Tarrance (1986)
- Ronne Troup as Rita Kendall
- This episode was loosely based on the 2000 murder of Krystal Dawn Steadman by Thomas Soria, Sr. and Jr. There are also elements drawn from the earliest attacks of the Zodiac Killer.
- The Hooters "And We Danced"
- Belinda Carlisle "Mad About You"
- Rick Springfield "Love Somebody"
- Michael Sembello "Maniac"
- Men Without Hats "Safety Dance"
- The Psychedelic Furs "Pretty in Pink"
- The Psychedelic Furs "Ghost in You"
- Closing Song: Stevie Nicks & Don Henley "Leather and Lace"