The team reopens the 1976 case of a murdered 17-year-old after a newfound photo of her on the back of a motorcycle exposes her connection to a notoriously nefarious gang.
- Kathryn Morris as Lilly Rush
- Danny Pino as Scotty Valens
- John Finn as John Stillman
- Jeremy Ratchford as Nick Vera
- Thom Barry as Will Jeffries
- Tracie Thoms as Kat Miller
- Jeff Fahey as Darren Malloy (2009)
- Beth Broderick as Libby Traynor (2009)
- Clayne Crawford as Darren Malloy (1976)
- Barry Cullison as Colin Blake (2009)
- Michael Raymond-James as John "Shameless" Clark (1976)
- Dylan Kenin as James "Monster" Drew (1976)
- Patrick Kilpatrick as James "Monster" Drew (2009):
- Brit Morgan as Libby Traynor (1976)
- Jeremy Roberts as Burke (2009)
- Michael Woods as Mark Callahan (2009)
- Simone Moore as Carmen Walters
- Keith Burke as SWAT Lieutenant
- Mark Hapka as Mark Callahan (1976)
- John Scarangello as Colin Blake (1976)
- Unknown actor as Burke (1976)
Shemar Reynolds' case box is visible when Scotty puts Sarah's case box away.
- Heart "Magic Man"
- Peter Frampton "Show Me The Way"
- Foghat "Slow Ride"
- Ted Nugent "Stranglehold"
- Bad Company "Bad Company"
- Closing Song: Lynard Skynard "Simple Man"