The team reinvestigates the 1953 case of a talented and discouraged 19-year-old rock'n'roll singer when new evidence comes forth suggesting he wasn't killed in the place where his body was found.
- Kathryn Morris as Lilly Rush
- Danny Pino as Scotty Valens
- John Finn as John Stillman
- Jeremy Ratchford as Nick Vera
- Thom Barry as Will Jeffries
- Tracie Thoms as Kat Miller
- James Snyder as Bingo Zohar (1953)
- Danielle Bisutti as Juliana Valentine (1953)
- Diana Douglas as Juliana Valentine (2007)
- Jennifer Rhodes as Miranda Allison (2007)
- Brandon O'Neil Scott as Arthur "Aces" Brown (1953)
- Peter White as JP Valentine (2007)
- Grant Alan as JP Valentine (1953)
- Cal Gibson as Arthur "Aces" Brown (2007)
- James Otis as Lloyd Jordan (2007)
- Alexis Wolfe as Miranda Allison (1953)
- Judd Fish as Luke Hartmere (1953)
- Kevin T. McCarthy as Store Owner (2007)
- Caon Mortenson as Lloyd Jordan (1953)
- Wiley Pickett as Ed Valentine (1953)
- Tex Beneke "Dimples and Cherry Cheeks"
- Wynonie Harris "Bloodshot Eyes"
- Billy Ward & The Dominoes "The Sixty Minute Man"
- Big Mama Thornton "Hound Dog"
- Perry Como & The Fontaine Sisters "Noodlin' Rag"
- Closing Song: Elvis Presley "Can't Help Falling in Love"