Carrie in 1998
|Portrayed by||Kayla Mae Maloney|
Carrie Swett was the victim in the episode 5X02. She was murdered in 1998 by her friends in the Hearts Wait Club.
Carrie Swett's case was re-opened in 2007 by Lilly in 2007 after a shirt discovered to be Carrie's was found in an abandoned van. Carrie had a reputation for being promiscuous, and it was discovered that the tank top was actually left in there from a time that someone had pulled a prank on her.
When Lilly interviewed the Hearts Wait Club, they all confessed that they killed her because she had "tainted" them. One girl had a pregnancy scare with her boyfriend, and another was accused by Carrie of being homosexual. They stoned her, because it was in the bible: "Thou shalt stone the whore." They were all arrested and put in jail.
Carrie had joined the purity club to "start over" and "re-purify", and the club's sponsor was a chief suspect, as he had an affair with a girl in the club. He disclosed that a threat to Carrie was placed in the secrets bin, and that Carrie knew that she would die, and that her "friends" had planned it.