After determining the serial killer's identity - and some of his likely future targets - the team and the FBI work together to apprehend him while trying to locate and protect the people he's preparing to kill.
- Kathryn Morris as Lilly Rush
- Danny Pino as Scotty Valens
- John Finn as John Stillman
- Jeremy Ratchford as Nick Vera
- Thom Barry as Will Jeffries
- Tracie Thoms as Kat Miller
- Johnny Messner as Ryan Cavanaugh
- JB Blanc as Paul Shepard (1998/2010)
- John D'Aquino as Kenneth Hoag
- John Gries as Bill Shepard
- Sonita Henry as Juanita Renaldo
- Peter Jason as Charlie Gleason (2010)
- Elisabeth Noone as Rita Gleason (2010)
- Azura Skye as Claire Shepard (1998/2010)
- Melissa Ordway as Diane Yates (1980)
- Jonathan Brett as Paul Shepard (1978)
- Bryan Cuprill as Brian Duke
- Morgan Benoit as Theodore Kutler
- Lee Dawson as Charlie Gleason (1978)
- Ronald F. Hoiseck as Ned Cotner ("Ned Jenkins")
- Mette Holt as Rita Gleason (1978)
- Barry Alan Levine as Tom Gleason (2010)
- Joshua Stilley as Tom Gleason (1978)
- Part 2 of a two-part episode (along with Last Drive-In).
- Jeremy Ratchford does not appear in this episode.
- For the first time since Death Penalty: Final Appeal, the main actors are not credited in an opening sequence. Instead they are listed afer a brief title sequence as the episode plays.
- Ronald F. Hoiseck is credited as portraying "Ned Jenkins" in the end credits for this episode and the previous one, however he is named as "Ned Cotner" in the episode.
- Townes Van Zandt "Snake Song"
- Death Cab for Cutie "Pity and Fear"
- Jenny Lewis "Bad Man's World"
- The National "Start a War"
- Dave Matthews Band "Crash Into Me"
- State Radio "Keepsake"