A woman asks Lilly to reopen the case of her son Angus, who was murdered in 1978, the night he and his friends saw the slasher film Halloween. They learn several people blamed Angus for a car accident that had left the girl he loved in a wheelchair. The case brings up some difficult memories for Jeffries as it reminds him of the hit and run that killed his wife a decade earlier.
- Kathryn Morris as Lilly Rush
- Danny Pino as Scotty Valens
- John Finn as John Stillman
- Jeremy Ratchford as Nick Vera
- Thom Barry as Will Jeffries
- Mimi Kennedy as Elena Bistrong (1978/2005)
- Dave Power as Craig (1978)
- Sarah Brown as Josie Sutton
- Jonathan Murphy as Angus Bistrong (1978)
- Hillary Tuck as Vicky Leoni (1978)
- Caryn West as Vicky McGowan (2005)
- Gareth Williams as Ian McGowan (2005)
- Jason Arden as Young Patrolman
- Alissa Dean as Donna
- Dennis Garber as Alex Leoni (1978/2005)
- Brian Jude Leahy as Older Fireman
- Jordan Moser as Devon Leoni (1978)
- Kyle Reed as Devon Leoni (2005)
- Maria Quiban as TV Anchor
- Unknown actress as Mary Jeffries
- John Carpenter - theme from the movie Halloween
- Tom Petty "American Girl"
- Fleetwood Mac "Go Your Own Way"
- Player "Baby Come Back"
- David May "I'll Let You Sleep"
- Girth "Bitter Lies"
- Styx "Come Sail Away"
- Closing Song: Aerosmith "Dream On"